Coastal Waters

Ash from the Lahaina wildfires may enter coastal water through surface water runoff and windblown ash. The ash may contain substances including arsenic, other metals, and asbestos, which can be harmful to human health. Stormwater best management practices (BMPs) throughout Lahaina have helped prevent runoff from carrying ash to the ocean, and spraying Soiltac® on soil and other surfaces has helped prevent winds from blowing ash into the ocean.  

DOH and partners continue to monitor the quality of nearshore coastal waters. This monitoring helps to answer the following questions:

  • Have the Maui wildfires affected nearshore water quality?
  • Is it safe for people to swim, fish, and enjoy other forms of recreation in waters near Lahaina without significant health impacts caused by the wildfires?
  • Do additional steps need to be taken to prevent the settled ash in Lahaina from entering the ocean?
Two men and a woman testing water in the field.
DOH contractor team processing water quality samples at Olowalu surf break monitoring site.

DOH is reviewing the following sampling efforts:  

  • DOH collects routine water quality indicators every week from nearshore monitoring sites. These indicators include dissolved oxygen, pH, salinity, and turbidity. A summary of recent DOH data is presented here. DOH is also collecting nearshore water quality data for metals (total and dissolved), nutrients, and other water quality indicators to further evaluate potential impacts from the wildfires.
  • Hui O Ka Wai Ola (HOKWO) has collected water chemistry and nutrient data monthly or bimonthly from 12 sites in the Lahaina area. They will be assisting DOH in collecting upcoming quarterly monitoring for metals and nutrients. A summary of recent Hui O Ka Wai Ola data is presented here.
  • The Surfrider Foundation’s Maui Chapter collected grab ocean water samples on January 10, 2024, following a heavy rainfall event and analyzed the samples for metals and polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAHs). Surfrider also collected samples on June 4, 2024, this time using DOH sample collection guidance to evaluate fire-related metals. The most recent Surfrider sampling data can be found here.
  • The University of Hawaii at Manoa is conducting ongoing research on coastal water quality following the Lahaina fires. The UH results are summarized in a YouTube video from a public presentation on March 11, 2024.
  • U.S. Geological Survey (USGS) conducted limited water quality sampling and DOH is currently receiving and reviewing data from these sampling efforts. While the data provide context, they are preliminary and not suitable for decision-making. These data were not collected using DOH protocols or EPA protocols and methods, so DOH cannot verify the quality or representativeness of the samples or the analytical data. DOH is not using these data to inform decision-making.

To evaluate impacts from the wildfires, DOH and partners collect nearshore water samples from nine sites near Lahaina (Figure 1). The sampling occurs at seven beaches and two surf breaks.

Tables 1 through 3 present the summaries of coastal water quality sampling data collected by DOH during August 2024 for total and dissolved metals, nutrients, and conventional water quality parameters. Table 4 shows water quality data from various locations for temperature, salinity, dissolved oxygen, pH, and turbidity, comparing overall water quality data before and after the Lahaina fires.

DOH will continue to collect nearshore water quality samples and will post sampling results to this page.

Two people in a kayak on in the Lahaina Harbor
DOH contractor team sampling water quality from a sea kayak near Lahaina Harbor.

 

Figure 1. DOH nearshore water quality monitoring locations in Lahaina and surrounding areas.
Figure 1. DOH nearshore water quality monitoring locations in Lahaina and surrounding areas.
Table 1. Results from nearshore water quality samples collected by DOH during August 2024 for total metals, in micrograms per liter (µg/L). 
Parameters (Total) DOH EAL:
Surface Water
Action Level
for Marine Habitats
(Ecological)1
Hanakao’o Park Mala WharfPuunoa (Baby) BeachKamehameha
Iki Park
Shark Pit -
Puamana 
Launiupoko
Beach
Launiupoko Beach
Surf Break 
Olowalu Surf
Break
Kahekili (Airport)
Beach 
Aluminum 11695.847.316.618.210.449.542.931.934.152.357.137.323.227.142.820.5NDND
Antimony300.1360.1090.1320.2520.1760.0780.0970.0770.0860.0840.0860.0870.0870.140.0760.1050.0820.1040.094
Arsenic0.141.021.10.7670.990.6760.7310.6660.971.090.8870.7740.7890.7030.9130.8520.8450.7650.6230.664
Beryllium 0.0380.0180.01NDNDNDND0.005*0.005*0.006*ND0.005*NDND0.005*0.006*0.005*NDNDND
Cadmium 9.30.086ND0.0250.0430.0280.0490.0330.0560.0540.0530.0230.0210.030.0430.0580.0320.0370.0240.025
Chromium 500.3860.3720.2870.1720.1610.1530.3010.2790.9230.2510.3810.5350.320.2180.230.5350.2350.1450.143
Cobalt 23NDNDNDNDNDNDNDNDNDNDNDNDNDNDNDNDNDNDND
Copper 2.90.3010.2430.1930.0830.1540.1310.1880.1820.1670.1590.1580.1810.1460.1290.1320.2280.1380.0410.025
Iron 88.555.237.77.07101.9122.914.418.113.427.936.425.913.412.140.48.951.171.34
Lead5.60.0840.0570.0850.0390.0350.0450.0260.0250.020.020.0260.0350.0280.020.0220.0280.0120.0120.009
Manganese 1.833.870.8830.620.5380.190.8081.381.671.081.671.781.051.461.671.070.5910.1640.178
Mercury0.025NDNDNDNDNDND0.004*0.003*0.003*0.004*ND0.003*ND0.003*0.0050.002*NDNDND
Molybdenum 37010.19.929.549.549.119.59.047.869.998.789.629.318.9213.27.749.116.610.310.4
Nickel8.30.6090.4690.3050.1680.1350.1380.2620.2440.2160.2960.2620.3080.2290.190.2330.4660.2060.1430.132
Selenium710.0320.0430.0470.0290.063NDND0.015NDND0.0280.0220.0230.0310.016*0.018*0.032NDND
Silicon0.3460.386ND0.0470.0070.0730.1460.0570.080.013NDND0.093ND0.0070.1930.1530.0670.04
Silver0.10.270.070.0640.0750.0420.0770.1560.190.1930.1890.1560.1770.1490.1850.1920.170.1410.0470.065
Thallium 12NDNDNDNDNDNDNDNDNDNDNDNDNDNDNDNDNDNDND
Tin 0.404NDNDNDNDND0.3380.3180.2810.3250.4180.5760.3960.2460.3270.350.271NDND
Titanium6.965.754.571.421.340.5344.623.672.592.686.246.444.092.112.385.362.210.107ND
Vanadium 812.472.461.861.821.751.771.71.651.841.741.861.91.81.691.781.841.711.651.78
Zinc 861.21.410.5171.240.2670.5171.242.412.220.6810.9142.191.12.831.110.8160.4550.5490.637

Coastal water quality samples were collected by DOH in accordance with DOH protocols.
DOH EAL: Hawaii DOH Environmental Action Level for screening. An entry of “—” means the analyte does not have an EAL.
The table shows valid sampling results from the sites, including duplicate and triplicate samples collected for quality assurance purposes.
Concentrations higher than DOH EALs are shown in bold font.
ND: Non-detect
*Values were J flagged in the laboratory report, indicating that the result should be considered as an estimated rather than quantitative value.
1Surface water EALs are for marine habitats and primarily consider potential harm to aquatic habitats or the potential for substances to accumulate in aquatic species. The EALs are from Table D-2b of DOH’s TGM EAL Surfer (found here: Environmental Hazard Evaluation and Environmental Action Levels – HEER Office (hawaii.gov)) from Spring 2024. Recreational water criteria for human health are based on bacteria levels in the water. See “What Do the Data Tell Us?” for explanations of why the levels shown here do not pose a risk to people using these waters for recreation.

Table 2. Results from nearshore water quality samples collected by DOH during August 2024 for dissolved metals, in micrograms per liter (µg/L).
Parameters (Dissolved) DOH EAL:
Surface Water
Action Level
for Marine Habitats
(Ecological)1
Hanakao’o Park Mala WharfPuunoa (Baby) BeachKamehameha
Iki Park
Shark Pit -
Puamana 
Launiupoko
Beach
Launiupoko Beach
Surf Break 
Olowalu Surf
Break
Kahekili (Airport)
Beach 
Aluminum 9.4610.24.26*3.74*4.57*5.08*8.53118.1410.19.31158.588.697.385.02*4.24*NDND
Antimony300.1290.1070.1250.2520.1090.030.0950.0430.0590.0740.0490.0730.0830.0780.0620.0940.0510.1020.031
Arsenic0.141.010.5760.5040.760.5180.6380.5510.8570.5570.8070.730.4660.5960.6650.4280.660.5230.6270.556
Beryllium 0.0380.0140.0120.038NDNDNDNDND0.005*0.0110.005*NDND0.01ND0.005*ND0.008*ND
Cadmium 9.30.058ND0.022ND0.0090.0110.0360.0430.0280.030.0180.0180.0280.0290.0360.0180.0370.0250.01
Chromium 500.1640.2060.1680.1310.1340.1160.1720.2540.190.1950.2570.3490.2220.1940.1940.2020.2060.1440.131
Cobalt 23NDNDNDNDNDNDNDNDNDNDNDNDNDNDNDNDNDNDND
Copper 2.90.1490.170.1350.0820.1510.1130.1480.1170.1290.1530.1560.1510.1340.1370.1280.1350.1260.0370.018
Iron NDNDNDNDNDNDNDND13.1NDNDNDNDNDNDNDNDNDND
Lead5.60.0140.0180.0180.0080.003*0.0060.003*ND0.003*0.0050.007ND0.003*0.01ND0.004*ND0.0120.005
Manganese 0.380.1910.1880.2470.0660.1870.2290.4220.2790.3170.640.3110.3510.3980.2170.1680.2220.1530.08
Mercury0.025NDNDNDNDNDND0.0040.004*0.003*0.004*ND0.003*ND0.003*0.004*NDNDNDND
Molybdenum 3709.79.899.39.29.19.39.067.389.28.29.29.38.513.17.48.96.1810.610.5
Nickel8.30.1670.1470.1350.1020.0940.0920.1430.1950.1570.1680.1710.1650.1750.1590.1820.1230.1940.1380.128
Selenium710.006*0.0440.0460.0280.0590.047ND0.017NDND0.0230.019*0.019*0.0310.014*0.018*0.030.02ND
Silicon0.3250.365ND0.05250.0050.0320.1260.0530.079NDNDND0.093NDNDND0.1260.0520.012
Silver0.10.1160.0720.070.0550.0330.0740.1450.1780.1630.1790.1580.1450.150.1510.1550.1310.1420.0390.068
Thallium 12NDNDNDNDNDNDNDNDNDNDNDNDNDNDNDNDNDNDND
Tin 0.1130.054NDNDNDND0.2860.3060.2790.3190.3430.2680.3210.250.2690.3210.206NDND
Titanium0.10.1310.06*0.051*0.077NDND0.065*0.05*0.063*0.0710.0850.054*0.118ND0.064*0.038*0.051*ND
Vanadium 812.322.141.61.581.531.661.551.491.571.731.791.61.691.651.611.671.561.61.67
Zinc 861.151.140.461.030.1990.5011.182.12.160.70.7631.121.072.661.040.7740.4630.520.586

Coastal water quality samples were collected by DOH in accordance with DOH protocols.
DOH EAL: Hawaii DOH Environmental Action Level for screening. An entry of “—” means the analyte does not have an EAL.
The table shows valid sampling results from the sites, including duplicate and triplicate samples collected for quality assurance purposes.
Concentrations higher than DOH EALs are shown in bold font.
ND: Non-detect
*Values were J flagged in the laboratory report, indicating that the result should be considered as an estimated rather than quantitative value.
1Surface water EALs are for marine habitats and primarily consider potential harm to aquatic habitats or the potential for substances to accumulate in aquatic species. The EALs are from Table D-2b of DOH’s TGM EAL Surfer (found here: Environmental Hazard Evaluation and Environmental Action Levels – HEER Office (hawaii.gov)) from Spring 2024. Recreational water criteria for human health are based on bacteria levels in the water. See “What Do the Data Tell Us?” for explanations of why the levels shown here do not pose a risk to people using these waters for recreation.

Table 3. Results from nearshore conventional water quality parameter sampling collected by DOH during August 2024, in milligrams per liter (mg/L). 
ParametersHanakao’o
Park
Mala WharfPuunoa (Baby)
Beach
Kamehameha
Iki Park
Shark Pit -
Puamana
Launiupoko BeachLauniupoko Beach Surf BreakOlowalu Surf BreakKahekili (Airport) Beach
Ammonia (as N)0.011*0.011*0.018*0.01*0.011*0.013*0.011*0.01*0.012*0.011*0.011*0.009*0.013*0.012*0.012*0.01*0.013*0.011*0.011*
Dissolved Orthophosphate (as P)0.01870.02650.01630.01760.01730.01070.01710.02390.01760.02430.02410.01610.02510.01680.02410.0250.01930.02460.0248
Nitrate (as N)NDNDNDNDNDNDNDNDNDNDNDNDNDNDNDNDNDNDND
Nitrite (as N)NDNDNDNDNDNDNDNDNDNDNDNDNDNDNDNDNDNDND
Total Alkalinity115114112114112112116116114114113113114113113115113114115
Total Dissolved NitrogenNDNDNDNDNDNDNDNDNDNDNDNDNDNDNDNDNDNDND
Total Dissolved Phosphorus0.0407ND0.0330.0185*0.03970.0297*0.03370.03540.03970.04860.03440.03620.03940.03890.030.04290.03890.04020.0578
Total NitrogenNDNDNDNDNDNDNDNDNDNDNDNDNDNDNDNDNDNDND
Total Orthophosphate (as P)0.03210.02890.0183*0.0250.0173*0.0166*0.0280.02870.0176*0.02450.02450.0168*0.0166*0.0158*0.02410.0260.02410.02470.0249
Total PhosphorusND0.02030.027NDND0.0178*0.03570.0208NDND0.0195*ND0.05310.06480.019*0.02750.0183*NDND
Total Suspended Solids 8.357.553.92.83.0516.12.352.958.653.254.452.94.363.954.0810.25.11.851.75

Coastal water quality samples were collected by DOH in accordance with DOH protocols.
DOH does not currently have Environmental Action Levels (EALs) for the parameters listed in the table.
The table shows valid sampling results from the sites, including duplicate and triplicate samples collected for quality assurance purposes.
Note that recreational water criteria for human health are based on bacteria levels in the water.
ND: Non-detect
*Values were J flagged in the laboratory report, indicating that the result should be considered as an estimated rather than quantitative value.

Table 4. Water quality data collected in West Maui before and after the Lahaina fires.

Pre/Post Fire1Location2Temperature (°C)Salinity (ppt)Dissolved Oxygen (mg/L) pHTurbidity (NTU)
Min.Max.Avg.Min.Max.Avg.Min.Max.Avg.Min.Max.Avg.Min.Max.Avg.
Pre-FireFire Impacted Sites (Hanaka'o Beach south to Launiupoko Beach Park)23.429.526.633.1036.4035.205.117.066.257.988.328.150.7543.707.02
Post-FireFire Impacted Sites (Hanaka'o Beach south to Launiupoko Beach Park)23.831.926.724.2036.1035.225.717.226.387.958.258.110.4275.807.01
Pre-FireNorth Reference Area (Hanakaoo Point north to Kahekili Beach)23.32826.334.5036.7035.295.566.836.288.068.298.170.568.702.29
Post-FireNorth Reference Area (Hanakaoo Point north to Kahekili Beach)23.527.625.734.9735.9035.455.777.016.257.958.258.120.6510.902.93
Pre-FireOlowalu (Olowalu Shore Front to Mile Marker 14)22.730.526.934.9236.9035.515.847.226.407.998.198.090.8416.735.78
Post-FireOlowalu (Olowalu Shore Front to Mile Marker 14)2428.226.635.1036.0035.735.896.776.327.958.228.040.8713.134.05

1Pre-fire data range is from August 1, 2022, to August 7, 2023. Post-fire data range is from August 8, 2023, to March 31, 2024.
2Water quality data are based on DOH and Hui O Ka Wai Ola monitoring efforts.

 

Surfrider conducted two rounds of sampling on West Maui after the fire. In January 2024, Surfrider collected grab samples for metals and PAH analysis during a post-fire “brown water” event after almost 4 inches of rainfall. In June 2024, Surfrider collected samples in accordance with DOH’s multi-incremental sampling protocols and analyzed them for fire-related metals. Table 5 presents the most recent sampling results.

Table 5. Nearshore water quality data collected by Surfrider in west Maui on June 4, 2024, in micrograms per liter (µg/L).
Parameters DOH EAL:
Surface Water
Action Level
for Marine Habitats
(Ecological)1
Canoe
Beach
DT. Fleming
(Replicate 1)
DT. Fleming
(Replicate 2)
Mala TavernMala RampPapalaua St Lahaina Harbor 505 Front St.Shark PitOlowalu
Metals (Dissolved)
Aluminum11.23.723.616.2611.57.049.6312.110.77.45
Antimony300.1860.0980.1140.1260.0940.1310.1860.1250.1040.112
Arsenic 0.141.441.461.511.471.031.481.51.451.591.49
Beryllium 0.0380.0070.0070.0070.0050.0070.0050.0060.0080.0080.007
Cadmium9.3NDND0.004NDNDND0.004NDNDND
Chromium 500.2550.2520.2370.1850.1610.180.190.2690.1610.202
Cobalt 23NDNDNDNDNDNDNDNDNDND
Copper2.90.1980.2480.2950.1990.345.263.170.2670.2460.214
Iron NDNDNDND0.583NDNDNDNDND
Lead 5.6ND0.005NDNDNDND0.080.006ND0.009
Manganese 0.4640.6460.6010.611.164.182.420.9240.7241.14
Mercury0.025NDNDNDNDNDNDNDNDNDND
Molybdenum3707.86.217.647.545.68.088.178.157.797.09
Nickel8.30.2130.1760.1850.1640.1730.2070.3520.1880.1790.164
Selenium71NDNDND0.0050.0090.017ND0.0060.011ND
Silver0.10.0580.0550.050.050.0570.0550.0560.0540.0640.062
Thallium12NDNDNDNDNDNDNDNDNDND
TinNDNDNDNDNDNDNDNDNDND
Titanium0.050.06NDND0.050.080.07ND0.090.16
Vanadium812.662.142.151.962.41.931.821.92.12.31
Zinc 865.021.731.841.480.881.279.911.720.9260.643

Water quality data provided from the Surfrider Foundation monitoring efforts.
DOH EAL: Hawaii DOH Environmental Action Level for screening. An entry of “—” means the analyte does not have an EAL.
Concentrations higher than DOH EALs are shown in bold font.
ND: Non-detect
PAH samples not collected for Canoe Beach 2 site
1Surface water EALs are for marine habitats and primarily consider potential harm to aquatic habitats or the potential for substances to accumulate in aquatic species. The EALs are from Table D-2b of DOH’s TGM EAL Surfer (found here: Environmental Hazard Evaluation and Environmental Action Levels – HEER Office (hawaii.gov)) from Spring 2024. Recreational water criteria for human health are based on bacteria levels in the water. See “What Do the Data Tell Us?” for explanations of why the levels shown here do not pose a risk to people using these waters for recreation.

Nearshore water quality monitoring conducted by DOH, Hui O Ka Wai Ola, Surfrider, and University of Hawaii continues to help DOH evaluate possible impacts of the wildfires on human health and the environment. Sampling to date shows that fire-related substances are not present at levels of human health or ecological concern. The coastal waters around Lahaina are safe for ocean recreation.

Ongoing nearshore monitoring data show that the water chemistry has stayed relatively consistent before and after the fires. This includes parameters such as temperature, salinity, pH, and turbidity. Conventional water quality parameters such as nutrient levels continue to be monitored to evaluate if they meet DOH water quality standards as set forth in Hawaii Administrate Rules (HAR) Chapter 11-54. DOH has developed these water quality standards to protect human health and aquatic life. The standards describe the desired condition of a water body, how the condition of the water body will be achieved, and controlling substances entering water bodies. Measured parameters to date fall within targeted ranges.

Based on ash data collected in the Lahaina and Kula burn areas, the fire-related substances of primary interest include metals. Therefore, water quality samples were analyzed for the same metals that were found at elevated levels in ash. To evaluate potential human health risk during recreational use of nearshore waters and ecological risks, DOH considered multiple lines of evidence. This included comparing sample results to the DOH Environmental Action Levels (EALs) for marine habitats (shown in the tables above) as well as other ecological screening values and health-based guidelines. The marine habitat EALs primarily consider factors such as bioaccumulation (how substances build up in an organism) and aquatic habitat toxicity. DOH also sets acute and chronic values for aquatic life for some metals under HAR 11-54, which generally align with DOH’s EALs. The U.S. Environmental Protection Agency sets ambient water quality criteria for some of the metals tested, which are comparable to DOH values.

Ecological screening values are typically set lower than criteria used for assessing potential risk to people using waters for recreation. However, no human health EALs have been developed for metals or other chemical substances for screening recreational waters. Public health agencies generally assess recreational water safety based on microbial criteria (like bacteria), which inform, for example, DOH Brown Water Advisory(ies). Setting guidelines for substances in recreational waters would need to take into account the multiple possible ways people may be exposed (e.g., the extent of skin contact, accidental ingestion) to these substances. The World Health Organization (WHO), however, recommends a simple screening approach for exposures associated with recreational activities. WHO recommends screening values at 20 times established safe drinking water standards to account for the small amount of water that may be accidentally swallowed during recreational activities. Collectively, fire-related substances tested in nearshore waters fall below WHO screening levels, indicating coastal waters around Lahaina are safe for recreation. This conclusion is consistent with previous DOH news releases.

The metals sampling results collected by both DOH and Surfrider are generally below the most stringent EALs for marine habitats and below HAR 11-54 screening values for acute and chronic scenarios for aquatic life. Slightly elevated levels of arsenic and silver are not expected to be harmful to human health. All reported metal levels (total and dissolved) are well below available WHO recreational water screening values.

Of note, Surfrider samples were collected during a “brown water” event, which likely reflects a worst-case condition for runoff and disturbance of any ash-contaminated sediments. Also, metal concentrations measured in nearshore coastal waters are not at levels beyond what might be normally expected. Volcanic soils on Maui have naturally high levels of metals in comparison to typical soils on the mainland United States, including aluminum, iron, manganese, and titanium. These naturally occurring metals could affect the levels of metals in sediment and nearshore coastal waters but are tightly bound to minerals in the soil and do not pose a health risk to residents or aquatic habitats. A report on the background concentrations of metals in Hawaii sediments is located here.

PAHs were detected at only two Surfrider sampling locations collected in January 2024 and at levels well below health-based screening levels. The sampling focus therefore remains on metals.